Best Artificial Pumpkins: Our Top Picks and Buying Tips

We looked for realistic color and texture, sturdy materials and sets that are easy to style. These three cover the most common uses for the best artificial pumpkins: larger statement pieces, a budget friendly filler set and weighty resin pumpkins that stay put on a porch step.

Best Overall: Artmag 6 Inch Large Artificial Pumpkins, 4 Pack

Many faux pumpkin sets are tiny bowl fillers. This Artmag set gives you four larger foam pumpkins, each about 6.1 inches tall and 5.1 inches wide, with tall, slender shapes and plastic stems that look freshly picked.

• Dense foam: smoother and sturdier than hollow plastic, with a natural matte look.
• Useful size: big enough to anchor a centerpiece or sit on a shelf without looking like a toy.
• Paintable: the plain surface takes acrylic paint if you want white, sage or metallic pumpkins.

Foam is light, so these pumpkins can tip in a breeze on an open porch. They suit tables, mantels and covered entryways, at around $35 for the set.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Value: Artgar Pumpkin Decor Set, 23 Pieces

This Artgar bundle is one of the most reviewed fall decor sets on Amazon, holding a 4.4 star average from about a thousand buyers. It includes 9 lifelike pumpkins plus acorns, pinecones, leaves and other fillers, so one box can dress a whole table or tiered tray.

• Complete look: the mix of pumpkins and natural fillers styles a centerpiece in minutes.
• Polyethylene foam: light, reusable and safe to handle around kids.
• Flexible use: works for bowls, wreaths, vases and DIY craft projects.

The pumpkins are small, so they will not stand out on a porch or lawn. For indoor fall decor on a budget, it is hard to beat at around $13.

Check Price on Amazon

Best for Curb Appeal: AOMOONOA Resin Pumpkins, Brown and White

Resin gives these pumpkins weight, which matters on a porch step or a windowsill by the front door. The pair includes a taller piece of about 6.7 inches and a shorter one of about 4.3 inches, both with faceted surfaces in a white and brown farmhouse finish.

• Solid resin: heavier than foam, so they resist tipping and do not dent.
• Two sizes: pairing heights makes a balanced, styled look.
• Neutral colors: carry from Halloween straight through Thanksgiving.

There are only two pieces, so you will need more for a big display, and resin finishes can fade in strong sun. They suit covered porches and entry tables, at around $20.

Check Price on Amazon

Artificial pumpkins come in foam, plastic, resin, velvet and ceramic. The right choice depends on where they will sit, how realistic you want them and how much storage space you have.

Indoor vs Outdoor Rating

Foam and velvet pumpkins are made for indoor or covered spaces. Rain soaks velvet and can loosen glued stems. Resin, ceramic and solid plastic handle a covered porch well, and blow molded plastic pumpkins are the best choice for open lawns. Strong sun can fade painted finishes over a long season, so rotate pieces or keep them in partial shade.

Realism is the other half of the equation. Look for uneven ribs, slightly irregular shapes and matte rather than glossy paint, since real pumpkins are never perfectly round or shiny. Natural looking stems made of twisted wire or textured plastic also make a big difference when guests see the pumpkins up close.

Size and Visual Impact

Mini pumpkins of 2 to 4 inches work as bowl fillers and table scatters. Medium pumpkins of 5 to 8 inches anchor centerpieces and shelves. For steps and porches, you need pieces of 10 inches or more to read from the sidewalk. Grouping odd numbers, such as three or five pumpkins of different sizes, looks more natural than a perfect row.

Power Source

Most faux pumpkins have no power at all. Light up versions use batteries, often with a 6 hour timer, and some porch sized pumpkins plug in. If you want a glow at night, choose LED models with a timer so you are not swapping batteries every few days.

Scare Level and Audience

Plain orange, white and sage pumpkins suit both Halloween and Thanksgiving, which makes them a smart buy for decorators who want one set to last two months. Carved faces and glitter skulls lean fully into Halloween and come down after the 31st.

Durability and Storage

Foam pumpkins are light and pack into a bin easily but dent if crushed. Resin and ceramic last years but chip if dropped. Wrap heavier pieces in tissue or bubble wrap, and keep foam pieces on top of the box.

Setup Time

Faux pumpkins are the fastest fall decor there is: unpack and arrange. Light up versions need batteries installed and timers set, which adds a few minutes. Outdoors, a dab of museum putty or a hidden brick keeps light pieces in place.

Here is a quick comparison of the main styles.

Indoor Halloween decor

Foam and velvet sets shine on mantels, shelves and tiered trays, where they stay dry and clean.

Outdoor yard decor

For steps and lawns, choose larger, heavier pumpkins in resin or plastic. They resist wind and moisture better.

Animated and light up pieces

Some top rated artificial pumpkins include LED lights and timers that switch on at dusk, ideal for entryways.

Kid friendly decor

Soft foam and velvet pumpkins are safe for little hands and easy to decorate with stickers or paint.

Faux pumpkins mix easily with real plants and natural materials from the garden. For more ideas, see this roundup of the best halloween decorations.

Creating a Theme

For a pumpkin patch look, cluster faux pumpkins with potted mums, hay bales and dried corn stalks. A neutral farmhouse theme uses white, cream and sage pumpkins with eucalyptus. For Halloween, mix orange and black pumpkins with a few tombstones or ghosts. Our guide to the best outdoor halloween decorations has more ideas for the porch and yard.

Lighting and Placement

Place larger pumpkins at the base of planters and smaller ones on steps or windowsills. Add warm LED string lights or a solar spotlight so the arrangement glows after dark.

Weatherproofing

Keep foam and velvet under a porch roof. Weigh down light pieces outdoors with putty, and bring them inside before heavy rain or snow.

If you add lights, use battery LEDs or outdoor rated cords plugged into GFCI outlets, and route cords away from walkways where trick or treaters walk. Never place real candles inside or near foam pumpkins, which can melt or catch fire.

Light up pumpkins often use small batteries. Keep spare button batteries locked away from children and pets, and check that battery covers are screwed shut. On steps, place pumpkins to the sides so the path stays clear.

Common questions about faux pumpkin decor.

When should you put up Halloween decorations?

Most people decorate in early October. Neutral faux pumpkins can go up in late September and stay through Thanksgiving.

Are artificial pumpkins safe to leave outside in the rain?

Resin and plastic pumpkins handle rain well. Foam and velvet should stay under cover, since water can stain or soften them.

How do you store artificial pumpkins after Halloween?

Dust them, wrap heavier pieces in tissue and store everything in a lidded plastic bin with foam pieces on top.

What artificial pumpkins are best for families with young kids?

Soft foam or velvet pumpkins are the safest choice, since they are light and will not shatter if dropped.

Where can you buy artificial pumpkins online?

Amazon carries a wide range of artificial pumpkins for Halloween and fall, from mini filler sets to large porch pieces. The product table above lists our current picks.

The best artificial pumpkins save you from rot and squirrels while keeping the harvest look all season. The Artmag 6 inch set is the most versatile choice for centerpieces, the Artgar 23 piece bundle is the budget pick for indoor styling, and the AOMOONOA resin pair adds weight and farmhouse charm to a porch.

Check the product table above for current prices on Amazon and mix sizes for a natural display.